You've decided to add a fire pit to your backyard, creating a space for sharing stories and laughter under the night sky. Now, you need to choose the right type of fuel and uncertain which option to go for? What fuel will kindle the heart of your fire pit?
Understanding Each Fuel Type
As night falls and your fire pit is ready, the choice of fuel will determine how it lights up the evening at your outdoor space. Let's explore the characteristics of wood, natural gas, and liquid propane fire pits to help you select the perfect fuel for countless cozy evenings around the fire.
Wood Fire Pits
A wood fire pit is a classic choice, known for its traditional feel with the snap and crackle of burning wood. It provides strong heat, over 100K BTU, making it perfect for cold nights. The smell of burning wood adds to the atmosphere, and you can use it to roast marshmallows or grill food.
However, using a wood fire pit requires some skill and effort. You need to know how to build and maintain a fire, and you'll need some tools and accessories to keep it going. The cost for materials ranges from $300 to $800, and installation can add another $200 to $500. Even with these costs and the work involved, the warm, glowing fire and the joy it brings to gatherings make it a worthwhile investment.
Natural Gas Fire Pits
Natural gas fire pits are known for their efficiency and convenience. They connect directly to your home's natural gas supply, providing an endless fuel source. This means you don't have to worry about refilling tanks, giving you more time to enjoy the warmth.
The initial installation is more expensive and requires professional expertise to safely install the gas line. However, natural gas is cheaper than propane, leading to long-term savings.
Natural gas fire pits burn cleaner and are more environmentally friendly. While the flame might not be as bright as propane, maintenance is minimal. A permanent installation enhances your outdoor space, offering both cost efficiency and sophistication, making it a popular choice for commercial settings.
Liquid Propane Fire Pits
LP fire pits are designed for easy use. With a quick turn of a knob, the fire ignites, eliminating the need to gather and stack wood. They use a standard 20 lb propane tank, often hidden within the fire pit's base or a companion piece, ensuring a consistent flame without interruption. This steady fuel source means more time enjoying the warmth and less time on maintenance.
Safety is a top priority, and LP fire pits are a great choice for families. They produce no unpredictable sparks or embers, making them safer for gatherings with children or pets. The ability to control the flame precisely reduces risk, providing peace of mind.
LP fire pits are portable and clean. You can easily move them to different areas of your outdoor space, and the clean burn of propane means no smoke or ash to deal with.
Factors to Consider When Choosing a Fire Pit Fuel
Choosing the right fuel for your fire pit is similar to selecting the perfect wine for a special dinner, it should match your preferences, suit the occasion, and reflect your values. Here are key factors to consider:
1) Cost
When it comes to upfront costs, wood fire pits often emerge as the most cost-effective option. A basic setup with a metal frame and some stones or bricks will not break the bank. Ongoing expenses, however, like purchasing or chopping firewood, can add up over time.
Natural gas fire pits present a higher initial investment due to the infrastructure needed to bring gas flow to your pit. But once installed, the monthly cost could be lower compared to propane, based on utility rates and usage.
Liquid propane fire pits fall in-between, with the purchase of a propane tank and the fuel itself representing a moderate cost. Affordability in the long run must be weighed against the expense of replenishing your propane supply.
2) Installation and Setup
Installation can be a crucial factor when choosing a fire pit fuel. Here are the key points for each type:
-
Propane Fire Pits: These have a quick and straightforward setup, requiring no significant modifications to your outdoor space.
-
Natural Gas Fire Pits: These require the installation of gas lines, often needing professional help, which can increase the overall cost.
-
Wood Fire Pits: These are simple to assemble and get burning but require ample storage space for dry wood and starter materials.
Regardless of the type, safety should be a top priority during installation. Gas fire pits, in particular, need careful checks to prevent gas leaks.
3) Maintenance and Upkeep
Maintaining your fire pit is essential, though the effort varies between wood and gas fire pits.
Wood-Burning Fire Pits:
-
Routine Maintenance: After each use, remove ash and char to ensure safety and prepare for the next gathering.
-
Firewood Storage: Keep firewood dry and ready on a rack, which adds to the rustic charm and practicality.
Gas Fire Pits:
-
Low Upkeep: Maintenance involves occasional cleaning with a cloth and dusting.
-
Safety Checks: Regularly inspect for leaks and ensure the system is in good condition. This is critical for any gas appliance.
Regardless of the type, keeping your fire pit well-maintained ensures it remains safe and enjoyable, providing steady warmth night after night.
4) Environmental Impact
It's important to consider the environmental impact of your chosen fuel source.
Wood Fire Pits:
-
Environmental Footprint: While wood is a renewable resource, burning it releases harmful chemicals and contributes to air pollution, which can affect health, you should follow the best wood burning practices from the EPA.
-
Ecosystem Impact: Using natural wood can deplete local resources and affect wildlife.
-
Sustainable Practices: You can mitigate some impact by using recycled wood pallets or collecting fallen branches instead of cutting down trees.
Gas Fire Pits:
-
Lower Emissions: Both natural gas and liquid propane fire pits produce fewer emissions and less air pollution, making them a greener choice.
-
Energy Efficiency: Gas fire pits require less fuel to generate the same amount of heat as wood fires.
-
Non-Renewable: Natural gas is not renewable, but it is more environmentally friendly in terms of emissions compared to wood.
Each fuel type has its environmental impact. Wood fire pits can affect ecosystems and air quality, while gas fire pits contribute to climate change through carbon emissions. Balancing ambiance and ecological responsibility is key to making an informed decision.
5) Safety Measures for Fire Pits
Wood Fire Pits
-
Clear Surroundings: Ensure the area around the fire pit is free from flammable materials such as leaves, paper, and dry grass.
-
Proper Ventilation: Use the fire pit in an open, well-ventilated area to prevent smoke buildup and ensure proper air circulation.
-
Fire Extinguishing Tools: Always have a fire extinguisher, bucket of water, or sand nearby to quickly extinguish the fire if needed.
-
Monitor the Fire: Never leave a wood fire pit unattended. Keep a close eye on children and pets around the fire.
-
Extinguish Completely: Before leaving the fire pit, ensure the fire is fully extinguished. Spread the ashes and pour water over them until no hot embers remain.
Natural Gas Fire Pits
-
Professional Installation: Ensure the gas lines are installed by a certified professional to avoid leaks and ensure proper setup.
-
Regular Inspections: Frequently check gas lines and connections for leaks. Use a mixture of soap and water on connections; bubbles indicate a leak.
-
Proper Ventilation: Use the fire pit in a well-ventilated outdoor area to prevent gas buildup.
-
Safe Distance: Keep the fire pit away from buildings, overhangs, and flammable materials.
-
Emergency Shutoff: Know the location of the gas shutoff valve and how to use it in case of an emergency.
Liquid Propane (LP) Fire Pits
-
Check Connections: Regularly inspect hose connections for leaks using a soap and water solution. Look for bubbles to indicate leaks.
-
Tank Storage: Store propane tanks in an upright position and away from direct sunlight or heat sources.
-
Proper Ventilation: Use the fire pit in an open, well-ventilated area to avoid propane gas buildup.
-
Portable Safety: Ensure the fire pit is stable and on a flat surface to prevent tipping. Keep it away from flammable materials.
-
Emergency Preparedness: Always have a fire extinguisher nearby and know how to turn off the propane supply quickly.
As a final thought, we've summarized the most important things to consider for each fuel type at the table below, the decision for the fuel to pick will depend on your needs.
| Aspect |
Wood Fire Pits |
Natural Gas Fire Pits |
Liquid Propane (LP) Fire Pits |
| Cost Efficiency |
Lower initial cost, ongoing cost for wood |
Higher initial installation cost, cheaper long-term fuel |
Moderate initial cost, ongoing cost for propane tanks |
| Ease of Installation |
Simple assembly, requires storage for wood |
Requires professional installation of gas lines |
Easy setup, portable, requires propane tank |
| Maintenance |
Regular cleaning of ash, managing wood supply |
Minimal maintenance, periodic leak checks |
Low maintenance, occasional leak checks, tank refills |
| Environmental Impact |
Higher emissions, impacts air quality, uses renewable resource |
Lower emissions, non-renewable resource |
Lower emissions, portable, non-renewable resource |
| Heat Output |
High heat output (over 100K BTU) |
Consistent heat, generally lower BTU compared to wood |
Consistent heat, generally lower BTU compared to wood |
| Safety |
Requires attention to sparks/embers, fire extinguisher needed |
Needs professional installation, regular leak checks required |
Safe for families, controlled flame, regular leak checks needed |
| Convenience |
Requires effort to start/maintain fire |
Easy to use with a switch, continuous fuel supply |
Easy to start with a knob, portable, no need for wood |
| Cooking Capabilities |
Suitable for roasting/grilling over open flames |
Limited, mainly decorative |
Limited, mainly decorative |
| Portability |
Fixed position, requires storage for wood |
Fixed position due to gas line |
Highly portable, easy to move |
| Ambiance |
Traditional, rustic charm with crackling sounds |
Clean, modern look, less traditional ambiance |
Clean, modern look, consistent flame |
